The Saudi Royal Family is reportedly worth more than $1.4 trillion, but for several years, the Pentagon has been chasing the kingdom for $15 million it owes for American assistance during the Saudi war in Yemen. Despite the unpaid debt, the Biden administration announced last Friday that it is lifting a ban on selling offensive weapons to Saudi Arabia, authorizing an initial shipment of air-to-ground munitions to the Gulf kingdom. The ban had been in place for the past three years as a response to the heavy civilian casualties of the country’s campaign in Yemen but did not apply to sales of so-called defensive arms and military services. Those sales have amounted to almost $10 billion over the past four years.
Outstanding Debt and Unpaid Balance
The outstanding balance dates from an operation carried out between March 2015 and November 2018. The Pentagon spent about $300 million to fly aerial refueling missions to support the warplanes of Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, as those nations waged their war to shore up the government of Yemeni President Abd-Rabbu Mansour Hadi, who was overthrown by Iran-backed Houthi rebels. America also provided the Saudi military and its allies weapons, combat training, and other logistical and intelligence support.
A Pentagon report obtained exclusively by The Intercept finds that Saudi Arabia has repeatedly stiffed the United States on its outstanding fuel bill. After the kingdom and the United Arab Emirates paid off a large portion of the debt in 2021 and 2022, Saudi Arabia has paid just over $950,000 on a years-old balance that, as of late last year, totaled $15.1 million.
Lack of Transparency and Accountability
According to the report, which was obtained via the Freedom of Information Act, representatives of the Defense Logistics Agency and U.S. Central Command, which oversees U.S. military activity in the Middle East, traveled to Saudi Arabia’s capital, Riyadh, in March 2022 to meet with the Saudi Ministry of Finance and Saudi air force brass. “At that time, the Saudi MOF and the RSAF leadership expressed a willingness to pay remaining fuel debt owed to DLA Energy by December 2022,” reads the report. When U.S. officials again met with their counterparts, more than a year later, and raised the issue of the debt, Saudi officials said they were “not aware of the outstanding debt and requested some additional time to investigate the issue.” Late last year, according to the report, the debt was still unpaid.
The Lack of Response from the Pentagon
For months, The Intercept has contacted the Pentagon to ascertain if Saudi Arabia has paid any additional portion of the money owed. Return receipts show that the questions were read three times by Pentagon officials in April and May. Despite dozens of follow-up messages in recent months, the Office of the Secretary of Defense has never responded to The Intercept’s questions. At this same time, the Biden administration has been brokering billions of dollars in arms deals with the kingdom leading up to its lifting of the offensive weapons ban last week — part of a rapprochement policy aimed at strengthening ties with Persian Gulf autocracies in the face of the Gaza war and battles with Iranian proxies, as well as curbing Russian and Chinese influence in the Middle East.
The Yemen War and U.S. Involvement
The U.S.-backed Saudi-led war in Yemen, which deescalated following a 2022 truce, has directly or indirectly killed at least 377,000 people, including thousands of civilians slain in Saudi-coalition air strikes. A 2022 investigation by the Washington Post and Security Force Monitor at Columbia Law School’s Human Rights Institute found that a substantial portion of Saudi coalition air raids were carried out by jets developed, maintained, and sold by U.S. companies, and by pilots who were trained by the U.S. military. That same year, a Government Accountability Office report noted that between March 2015 and August 2021, the United Nations estimated that coalition airstrikes in Yemen killed or injured more than 18,000 civilians. The GAO also determined that the Pentagon and the State Department failed to investigate the role of U.S.-provided military support in causing these casualties.
The Biden Administration’s Relationship with Saudi Arabia
In 2018, Jamal Khashoggi, a Saudi dissident and critic of the war in Yemen who lived in Virginia and was a columnist for the Washington Post, was murdered and dismembered on the orders of Saudi leader Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, commonly referred to as MBS. Then President Donald Trump and senior members of his administration never wavered in their support for MBS, plying the Saudi regime with arms, even in the wake of the international outcry over Khashoggi’s killing. During his 2020 presidential election campaign, candidate Joe Biden excoriated the Saudis, vowing that, if elected, they would “pay the price” and he would “make them in fact the pariah that they are.” In 2021, the Biden administration imposed a ban on sales of certain types of offensive weapons to Saudi Arabia, citing the heavy civilian casualties in Yemen, but the new president quickly changed his tune. Biden offered warm greetings when they met in 2022 and 2023 and, since taking office, has provided the kingdom with more than $9 billion in deals for arms and other security assistance.
Conclusion
The resumption of offensive arms sales to Saudi Arabia and the lack of transparency and accountability regarding the unpaid debt raise concerns about the Biden administration’s relationship with Saudi Arabia. Despite the heavy civilian casualties and human rights violations associated with the Saudi-led war in Yemen, the administration has prioritized arms deals and strengthening ties with the kingdom. The lack of response from the Pentagon regarding the unpaid debt further highlights the larger problem of opacity surrounding arms deals and defense spending when it comes to the U.S. and Saudi Arabia. The Biden administration’s approach raises questions about its commitment to human rights and accountability in its foreign policy decisions.